| CHARACTER | FIRST APPEARANCE | SUGGESTED BY |
| 343 Guilty Spark | Halo: Combat Evolved | Eric |
| Agent 47 | Hitman: Codename 47 | Will |
| Alucard | Castlevania III: Dracula's Curse | Huberty |
| Annah | Planescape: Torment | Ian |
| Arthas | Warcraft III | Jared/Andy |
| Augustus ""Cole Train"" Cole" | Gears of War | Eric |
| Baal | Diablo II | Eric |
| Banjo | Diddy Kong Racing | Drew |
| Bill | Left 4 Dead | Ian |
| Bill | Starfox 64 | Jared |
| Billy Blaze/Commander Keen | Commander Keen | Ian |
| Bomberman | Bomberman | Jared |
| Captain Price | Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare | Jared |
| Cecil Harvey | Final Fantasy IV | Jared |
| Chris Redfield | Resident Evil | Brandon |
| Chrono | Chrono Trigger | Charles |
| Cloud Strife | Final Fantasy VII | Jared |
| Conker | Diddy Kong Racing | Drew |
| Dak'kon | Planescape: Torment | Ian |
| Dan Hibiki | Street Fighter Alpha | Jared |
| Darunia (Cool Goron?) | The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time | Huberty |
| Delita | Final Fantasy Tactics | Andy |
| Divyath Fyr | The Elderscrolls 3: Morrowind | Ian |
| Dizzy Wallin | Gears of War 2 | Will |
| Dr. Wily | Megaman | Huberty |
| Duckhunt Dog | Duckhunt | Ian |
| Earthworm Jim | Earthwrom Jim | Brandon |
| Epona | The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time | Huberty |
| Falls-From-Grace | Planescape: Torment | Ian |
| Francis | Left 4 Dead | Ian |
| Frog | Chrono Trigger | Andy |
| General Carville | Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2 | Will |
| Gex | Gex | Ian |
| Gordon Freeman | Half Life | Aaron |
| Gray Fox | Metal Gear | Huberty |
| Guybrush Threepwood | The Secret of Monkey Island | David |
| Harold | Fallout | Ian |
| HK-47 | Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic | Ian |
| Ignus | Planescape: Torment | Ian |
| JC Denton | Deus Ex | Eric |
| Jim Raynor | Starcraft | Drew |
| Joanna Dark | Perfect Dark | Eric |
| Jobasha | The Elderscrolls 3: Morrowind | Ian |
| Kain Highwind | Final Fantasy IV | Jared |
| King Hippo | Mike Tyson's PunchOut | Brandon |
| Kirby | Kirby's Dream Land | Eric |
| Klonoa | Klonoa: Door to Phantomile | Ian |
| Kratos | God of War | Will |
| Kyle Katarn | Dark Forces | Jared |
| Link (Fierce Deity Link) | The Legend of Zelda | Charles/Huberty/Aaron/Andy |
| Louis | Left 4 Dead | Ian |
| Luigi | Mario Bros. | Jared |
| Lulu | Final Fantasy X | Jared |
| Magus | Chrono Trigger | Mars |
| Mannimarco | The Elderscrolls 2: Daggerfall | Ian |
| Mario | Donkey Kong | Drew |
| Megaman | Megaman | Huberty/Jared |
| Miles ""Tails"" Prower" | Sonic the Hedgehog 2 | Huberty |
| Morte | Planescape: Torment | Ian |
| Peons | Warcaft II | Aaron |
| Protoman | Megaman 3 | Huberty/Jared |
| Raiden | Mortal Kombat | Eric |
| Rash and Zitz | Battletoads | Brandon |
| Raz | Psychonauts | Charles |
| Ryu | Breath of Fire | Mars |
| Ryu Hayabusa | Ninja Gaiden | Huberty |
| Sam and Max | Sam and Max Hit the Road | David |
| Sam Fisher | Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell | Will |
| Samus Aran | Metroid | Charles |
| Sarah Kerrigan | Starcraft | Charles/Mike/Andy |
| Scorpion | Mortal Kombat | Eric |
| Sephiroth | Final Fantasy VII | Andy |
| Shadow | Final Fantasy VI | Charles |
| Shadow Man | Megaman 3 | Huberty |
| Sheogorath | The Elderscrolls 2: Daggerfall | Ian |
| Shepard | Mass Effect | Jared |
| Simon Belmont | Castlevania | Huberty |
| Snake Man | Megaman 3 | Huberty/Andy |
| Soren | Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance | Huberty |
| Sub-Zero | Mortal Kombat | Jared |
| Tanya Adams | Command & Conquer: Red Alert | Aaron |
| The dude from Masterblaster | Masterblaster | Huberty |
| The King of All Cosmos | Katamari Damacy | Charles |
| The Nameless One | Planescape: Torment | Ian |
| The Terran Marine | Starcraft | Will |
| The Turret | Portal | Will |
| Toe Jam and Earl | Toe Jam and Earl | Brandon |
| Tomba | Tomba | Ian |
| Trevor Belmont | Castlevania III: Dracula's Curse | Huberty |
| Vincent Valentine | Final Fantasy VII | Jared |
| Vivec | The Elderscrolls 3: Morrowind | Ian |
| Wario | Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins | Mars |
| Weighted Companion Cube | Portal | Aaron |
| Worker 8 | Final Fantasy Tactics | Jared |
| Zero | Megaman X | Jared |
| Zhang Bao | Dynasty Warriors 3 | Andy |
| Zoe | Left 4 Dead | Ian |